There are 2 forms of eye disease that Staffordshire Bull Terriers
are known to suffer from these being Hereditary Cataracts (HC) &
Persistent Hyper Plastic Vitreous (PHPV) the article below was
written by Juanita Hobbs of Crossbow Staffordshire Bull Terriers
South Africa and she has kindly allowed me to use this article
here, but for further information and a much more in depth look at
these diseases please visit her website on this Link:
http://www.staffords.50megs.comThe following
article explains what WE as responsible owners and breeders of
this wonderful creature need to do in order to stop these terrible
diseases spiralling out of control, HOW WOULD YOU FEEL IF YOUR
BEAUTIFUL NEW PUPPY WAS BLIND BY THE TIME IT REACHED 2 YEARS OLD??
Hereditary
Cataracts (also called Juvenile Cataracts) is an inherited condition,
a cataract being opacity of the lens or its capsule. The age of
onset has been most commonly seen from 8 to 10 weeks of age up
to about 18 months, but has been seen as late as 3 years. It is
usually bilateral and symmetrical. Once the cataract becomes total
the dog is completely blind. This cataract is presumed to follow
an autosomal (not sex linked) recessive mode of inheritance.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
UNDERSTANDING
HEREDITARY CATARACTS (HC)
by Juanita Hobbs "Crossbow" (South Africa)
INTRODUCTION
A well-known
English stud dog, UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool, has recently produced
an HC-affected puppy, so there has once again been an uproar amongst
Staffordshire Bull Terrier fanciers around the world.
Accusations
and vile gossip has become the order of the day, and, inaccurate
statements and assumptions are being accepted as the "gospel
truth".
The most frightening
truth which has come to light is that an amazing number of "breeders"
do not understand the most basic facts about Hereditary Cataracts.
This new section
of our website is presented to provide as much factual information
as possible about Hereditary Cataracts in order to aid in defeating
the problem that exists in our Breed. We CAN eradicate this dreaded
genetic disease, and we CAN do it in an educated, effective, ethical
and efficient manner.
In order to
offer a broad spectrum of opinion you will find a wide variation
of information on this section of our website:
(1) This particular
article is written in layman's terms - but there are also several
expert articles available to read via the HC specific links page.
(2) There
is a direct link to the SBT Breed Council's webpage, as well as
a page with the updates on the HC DNA Project.
(3) There
is The 1971 List of names of carriers.
(4) There
are some of the pedigrees of the 1971 List of carriers.
(5) There
are various facts and figures.
(6) There
are details and pedigrees of the four publicly acknowledged 1990's
carriers - UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool & Jodel's Xavier and Jackstaff
Rustic Prince & UK Ch Jackstaff Heaven Sent.
PLEASE, if
you own or have bred a carrier, and you are prepared to make the
facts public and offer full details - e-mail us here. It doesn't
matter what country you live in, the information is relevant to
us all. Tell all your Stafford friends about it too - maybe they
don't have access to the Internet, and everyone needs to know.
It is our
hope that with the dissemination of such information we, as breeders,
will have the knowledge and the bravery to stand up and face the
problem head on.
Additionally,
we appeal to everyone to contribute anything they can to these
pages - whether it be pedigrees that we are missing, whether it
be educational articles, whether it be links to other relevant
sites, or whether it be names and pedigrees of carriers. The latter
takes a great deal of courage to contribute - but, we appeal to
you to do so - our Breed needs and deserves YOUR courage.
There is no
way to accurately state how prevalent the problem is in our Breed.
But, because most breeders do not regularly test their stock's
eyes, coupled with the fact that most breeders tend to sweep such
things as hereditary diseases under the carpet, I fear that there
may be more of it around than we'd like to admit. After all, many
of the expert articles call HC "common" or "prevalent"
in the Staffordshire Bull Terrier.
BASIC GENETICS
& HOW H.C. IS PASSED ON
The basic
unit of life is the cell. Inside the cell there are structures
called chromosomes. On the chromosomes there are a series of genes.
Genes are the units of inheritance.
Chromosomes
occur in pairs and each species has a constant number of pairs.
The dog has 39 pairs. Of these 38 are identical pairs and are
known as homologous chromosomes (autosomes). The 39th pair is
the sex chromosomes and they are not identical. The female possesses
two X chromosomes and the male has one X and one Y chromosome.
As I already
said, all the chromosomes other than the sex chromosomes are known
as autosomes and so a gene carried on an autosome is known as
an autosomal gene. Conversely, a gene carried only on the sex
chromosomes is called a sex-linked gene.
Each parent
contributes one of each pair of chromosomes to the puppy and so
it is luck of the draw which one of each pair of chromosomes is
transmitted. This is why the individual puppies in the same litter
are not identical.
This is a
very simplified scenario, but let us say these two animals are
mated:
Sire Dam
Aa Aa
There are
four possible combinations in the puppies produced:
AA Aa Aa*
aa
Pup 1 Pup 2 Pup 3 Pup 4
"A" from sire "A" from sire "a"
from sire "a" from sire
"A" from dam "a" from dam "A" from
dam "a" from dam
* Note: It
is expressed "Aa" rather than "aA" because
geneticists write the dominant symbol first.
In the same
way that chromosomes are paired, so are the genes which they carry.
In some pairs of genes, one is capable of suppressing the effect
of the other one. In this case, the first gene is known as a DOMINANT
gene, and the other one is known as a RECESSIVE gene.
Let us say
that in the above example the dogs are Labradors and A is the
gene for black and a is the gene for chocolate. In Labradors black
is dominant and chocolate is recessive. Therefore Pup 1 will be
black, Pup 2 will be black, Pup 3 will be black and Pup 4 will
be chocolate.
Pup 1 is black
because he inherited black from both parents. Pups 2 and 3 each
inherited one black gene, and one chocolate gene - but, because
black is dominant over chocolate they will both have black coats
themselves, BUT they are still CARRIERS of the chocolate gene
- in other words they both possess the chocolate gene. Pup 4 is
chocolate because he inherited chocolate from both parents - there
is no black gene present in him to suppress his chocolate colour.
To break it
down into likely percentages:
25% of the
offspring will be black and carrying only black genes ("AA");
50% of the offspring will be black and carrying chocolate genes
also ("Aa");
25% of the offspring will be chocolate and carrying only chocolate
genes ("aa").
Any progeny
produced by Pup 1 will only inherit the black gene from him because
he has only the black gene ("AA") to pass on. Likewise,
Pup 4 will only pass on to his progeny the chocolate gene because
he has only the chocolate gene ("aa"). Pups 2 and 3
are capable of passing on either black or chocolate genes to their
progeny because they themselves are carrying both genes ("Aa").
Therefore
the only way to guarantee that chocolate puppies will be produced
is to mate two chocolates together - because you know that the
parents can only be carrying chocolate genes. It is impossible
to get black puppies if two chocolates are mated together.
In our example
above, both parents are black coated but because they are both
carrying the chocolate gene, they are capable of producing chocolate
puppies. Just because you can't see the chocolate colour in the
parents doesn't mean that the chocolate gene is not present in
them.
Remember that
:
Can't see
doesn't mean not present.
This is the
problem with dominant genes - you can't see what genes they are
suppressing or hiding. Unless, of course, there is a DNA test
available for those specific genes.
So, let's
get back to Hereditary Cataracts and UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool.
UK Ch Jodel's
Mr Cool is a carrier of HC. He himself is NOT affected - in other
words, he DOES NOT have cataracts himself. In fact, he has been
TESTED CLEAR himself. However, he has produced an affected (blind)
puppy - and that is what makes him a carrier of the recessive
HC gene.
In HC the
"bad" gene is recessive. So "A" would be normal
eyes (dominant) and "a" would be hereditary cataracts
(recessive).
So in our
above example, Pup 1 ("AA") will have good eyes and
he is not carrying the HC gene, Pups 2 and 3 (both "Aa")
will have good eyes but they are both carrying the HC gene - and
you can't tell that by a simple eye test, you could only tell
that by a DNA test for HC. And, Pup 4 ("aa") will be
affected (blind with HC), because he only has the HC gene.
Pup 1 is not
blind (he will get an "eyes clear" certificate) because
he inherited good genes from both parents.
Pups 2 and
3 each inherited one good gene, and one bad gene. But because
the good gene is dominant over the bad gene they will not have
HC (not be blind) themselves (and, they will both get "eyes
clear" certificates). BUT they are still carriers of the
bad HC gene.
Pup 4 is blind
(affected) because he inherited bad genes from both parents -
there is no good gene present in him to suppress his HC gene -
and he so will not get an "eyes clear" certificate.
To make the
point absolutely clear:
Because the
HC gene is recessive ("a") this means that a blind puppy
must have inherited "a" from BOTH parents.
An affected
(blind) puppy is "aa" - so both his parents MUST be
"Aa" if they themselves were not blind.
Therefore
UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool is "Aa".
Now, ONLY
if UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool was mated to a bitch which was also "Aa"
can he have produced a blind puppy. This is exactly what happened.
The problem
is if you have a dog which is "Aa" and he is only ever
mated to "AA" bitches (i.e., bitches which are not carriers)
then it is not possible for a blind puppy ever to be produced
by him. BUT puppies which are carriers can be produced by him.
In fact, even
if both parents are carriers, it is possible that no puppies will
be blind - but they could all be carriers - it depends on the
fall of the dice, as does all genetics.
In this way
you could go on breeding for generations a whole long line of
carriers without ever producing a single blind puppy.
And then one
day, the proverbial hits the fan!
WHO TAKES
THE BLAME?
NO BLAME CAN
BE ATTACHED to anyone for this problem. Laureen & Eddie Williams,
the breeders of UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool have eye tested their stock
for six generations - and all their stock has been certified HC
clear up until this point. The Williams' have been completely
responsible throughout their breeding to test their stock. And
now, they have been completely responsible by bringing to public
attention what has happened so that everyone can have the chance
to pay vigilant attention to the pedigrees involved, and breed
(or not breed) accordingly.
This is a
quote from a Breed Lecture given by the Williams' in 1997 at the
Border Staffordshire Bull Terrier Club, East London, South Africa:
"Because
we are aware of the eye problems in our breed, we always have
our dogs tested before we breed from them. If we cannot have our
puppies eye tested before he or she leaves our home we ask the
new owners to have them tested as soon as they can, or most definitely
before they breed from him or her. It is most irresponsible not
to have his or her eyes tested, and, yes, we do know a lot of
breeders don't test.
Don't think
a litter from your bitch will do her good, it won't. If you don't
want to breed from her, don't - have her spayed, then you won't
have the problems with seasons. If you do want to breed we most
strongly recommend you wait until the bitch is at least 18 months
old. At that time she can be eye tested before she is mated."
There have
been people in the past who have bred dogs that have turned out
to be carriers of HC - and some of those people have been responsible
in the way the Williams' have been, and brought it out in the
open so that everyone can benefit.
And, some
have not been so responsible.
There is a
breeder in England who some years ago hid the fact that his dog
was a carrier, and KNOWINGLY allowed the dog to continue to stand
at stud. The consequences of this person's action are unimaginable
and horrifying.
It is however,
up to the people who have the bloodlines concerned to be very
careful when breeding. If they are not careful then they will
have to accept the consequences if something goes wrong for them
in the future. Does this include YOU?
THE ONLY PEOPLE
TO BLAME are the unscrupulous and irresponsible breeders that
there have been from time to time, who FAILED to do the right
thing. Probably these people were motivated by money or "international"
puppy sales - that is, "big bucks rules", and "ethics
are thrown out the window". These people were perfectly well
aware of the problem and they grossly neglected their responsibility
to the Breed by not telling the truth.
YOU MUST UNDERSTAND
that it is completely possible that no other stock from Jodel's
are carriers of the HC gene - and so there may be NOTHING further
to worry about as far as their bloodlines are concerned.
BUT until
the DNA test for HC in Staffords is developed and we can therefore
have all our Staffords DNA tested, we MUST always keep in the
back of our minds that any Stafford MAY be a carrier of the HC
gene.
WHILE WE WAIT
FOR THE DNA TEST TO BE DEVELOPED, WHAT CAN WE DO ABOUT IT?
The most important
thing YOU can do RIGHT NOW is:
Make a financial
contribution towards to DNA test's development. Click here for
further details. Or, e-mail Ivor Keyes with your pledge. Remember
every penny counts - so add a few of your own for the love of
Staffords.
And, it is
VITALLY IMPORTANT to understand that it is IMPERATIVE that dogs
of virtue are RETAINED in our breeding programs.
Once the DNA
test for HC in our Breed is developed, we CAN completely eliminate
Hereditary Cataracts in our Breed in ONE generation.
For example,
a litter could be bred from UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool once the test
is available. Virtually as soon as the puppies are born, a small
blood sample would be taken from each of them, and tested. It
would then be known without a doubt which puppies carried the
"bad" gene, and which didn't. The pups with the "bad"
gene would then immediately be eliminated from Breed's gene pool.
The pups that are thus proven not to carry the HC gene would then
be available to carry forward the very important virtues required
for the positive progress of our Breed as a whole.
Therefore,
it is we must take immediate and positive steps to ensure that
we do not lose virtuous, and thus invaluable, dogs such as UK
Ch Jodel's Mr Cool to our Breed. Whilst they may have withdrawn
their stud dogs from use, owners of any such dogs which are carriers,
or suspected carriers, must be proactively encouraged to take,
freeze and store semen from these dogs. As soon as the DNA test
is available, the semen can be used with absolute safety by simply
doing the DNA test on the pups produced.
This is exactly
what the Williams' have done, and they have been "hauled
over the coals" by the rumour mongers for storing Mr Cool's
semen - WHY???? Having faced such a tragedy with tremendous courage
and honesty, and then still to have managed to think about and
plan for the long term future, is more than admirable. Critics
of their actions are nothing less than short-sighted and ignorant.
Of course,
as an extra bonus to the development of the DNA test, puppy buyers
of the future will be able to insist on the results of their prospective
puppy's DNA test being produced by the breeder prior to purchase.
If this method
is followed to the letter once the DNA test is available - Hereditary
Cataracts will be eradicated from our Breed virtually overnight.
Otherwise,
as far as breeding in the meantime is concerned, if your stock
comes from one or more carrier lines, you have two choices:
(1) Never
breed from the stock again and have all progeny produced so far
neutered or spayed. And start again.
(2) Be extremely
circumspect in your breeding and breed away from the known carriers
in our Breed as quickly as possible.
Obviously,
choice (2) sounds far more agreeable!
If you choose
this route, you will have to learn to read pedigrees and make
sure that you don't breed your dogs to stock that descends from
any carriers of HC. Read the other pages of this section for names
and pedigrees of dogs which are carriers. UNDERSTAND before you
breed your Stafford.
It is also
vital to understand that IT IS NOT THE ANSWER to simply look for
the presence of one of these named dogs in the pedigree.
These dogs
are carriers of HC therefore they inherited the bad gene from
one of their parents. The gene DID NOT just suddenly appear in
any of these dogs from the middle of nowhere!
Therefore
either the mother AND / OR the father of any one of these dogs
HAVE TO BE CARRIERS of the gene. But, there is no way of telling
which one of them was responsible for the gene in their particular
progeny.
In addition,
whichever one of them is responsible will have inherited it from
one or both of his/her parents. So, this same principal must therefore
be applied the whole way back through the entire pedigree. As
you can see that means that there are an enormous number of dogs
which COULD BE CARRIERS of the HC gene. Be aware that you must
take all such dogs into consideration when planning a mating or
when agreeing to a mating.
To illustrate
the need for care, in the five generation pedigree of UK Ch Jodel's
Mr Cool there has to be a minimum of five Hereditary Cataract
carriers besides himself - one on each generation.
This mind-boggling
permutation is the place to start when considering a mating with
your stock.
CONCLUSION
It is very
important to understand when discussing UK Ch Jodel's Mr Cool
that:
(1) He is
NOT the only dog to blame.
(2) All his
other progeny MAY be completely HC-free - and they may NOT.
(3) It is
completely possible that all his other progeny are NOT even carriers
of the HC gene - and they MAY be.
The point
is that it is unwise to ASSUME that your stock is HC-free, regardless
of the dogs in your pedigrees. That is what ALMOST EVERYONE ELSE
has done.
Other breeders
have acted irresponsibly by allowing their dogs to be bred from
indiscriminately. The fact that they may not have been aware of
the consequences is no excuse - it is every breeder's duty to
understand exactly what is present in their pedigrees and to act
accordingly. The Breed's extremely bad state of affairs worldwide
is due to a very few breeders acting out of self-interest and
without any thought to the future effects. THERE IS ABSOLUTELY
NO EXCUSE FOR THESE BREEDERS' ACTIONS.
The fact is
that the Breed may never recover from what has been done to it
by a small minority.
It is up to
us to try and make things right - and this discussion is only
one of the many steps which need to be taken to put us back on
the right track.
If we wish
to claim to be "responsible and ethical breeders" then
it is up to us to take these steps to preserve our Breed in the
long term. Tomorrow's show wins are nothing when compared to the
long term future of the Breed.
Our ever-diminishing
gene pool means that unless we act responsibly, our Breed will
be riddled with various hereditary diseases such as Hereditary
Cataracts in a very short time - after all one generation in dogs
is only 18 months. When that happens it will be far more important
and significant to be a breeder of sound, healthy Staffords -
than just another breeder who sacrificed their stock's health
for the sake of a pile of worthless cards and rosettes.
Look, learn
- and, do the right thing - FOR THE LOVE OF STAFFORDS.